1. Home
  2. Services
  3. Areas we cover
  4. Local designer vs agency vs Wix
Choosing how to build your website

A local web designer, an agency or Wix and Squarespace?

There is no single best way to get a website, only the best fit for your budget, time and goals. This guide compares the three most common routes for small businesses in Dorset, Hampshire and beyond, including where DIY builders genuinely work well and where a local designer earns the difference. We are a local designer, so we say where we are not the right choice.

  • 170+ five-star Google reviews
  • Website Design Agency of the Year · South West England Prestige Awards 2024/25
  • 10+ years’ design experience
  • Serving Dorset, Hampshire and the New Forest
The short answer

Designer vs agency vs DIY, in short

DIY (Wix, Squarespace)
Lowest cost and quick for a simple site. You do the design, writing, SEO and upkeep yourself.
Local freelance designer
Direct contact, flexible pricing and a site built around your business and area. Capacity is limited to one person or a small team.
Agency
Larger team and process, often with extra services. Typically higher cost, and you may not deal with the person doing the work.
Best for most small businesses
A local designer or a pay monthly package: professional results without agency overheads.
Where we fit
A small Dorset studio. Pay monthly from £45 a month, or a fixed-price custom build.
Next step
Book a free call. If another route suits you better, we will say so.
The comparison

What each route is really good at.

Weigh them on what matters to you: time, money, control and results.

01

Cost

DIY is cheapest on paper. A local designer sits in the middle. Agencies usually cost the most for similar small-business work.

02

Time and effort

DIY costs your evenings. A designer or agency takes the work off you, which is often the real saving.

03

SEO and local visibility

Builders can rank when set up well, but most owners never get there. A designer builds structure, content and local set-up in from the start.

04

Control and ownership

Check export options and ownership. WordPress sites are widely portable, while hosted builders can lock you in.

05

Support

A local designer answers your call. Agencies route you through account managers. DIY platforms offer help articles.

06

Growth

If you will add pages, bookings or a shop, check the route can grow with you without a rebuild.

When each makes sense

Choose DIY, a local designer or an agency when…

A short guide to the decision.

DIY makes sense when

The site is simple, you enjoy the work and trade does not depend on the website.

A local designer makes sense when

You want the site to bring in customers and prefer to deal with one person who knows your area.

An agency makes sense when

The project is large, multi-team or needs a wide set of services under one contract.

Pay monthly makes sense when

You want a professional site now, without a large upfront bill.

Antony Locke, award-winning web designer at Creative Locker, on a client call in his Dorset studio
Let’s make something goodGood ideas start with a conversation.
Who you will work with

A designer who builds for enquiries, not just looks.

Antony Locke is a web designer first, with more than a decade of experience and over 100 websites built for small businesses. He starts with what your customers need to do, designs the site around that, and explains each choice in plain English.

Creative Locker is a small Dorset studio. You deal with Antony from the first call to launch and beyond, not an account manager or an overseas team. He has built more than 100 websites since 2020, the studio was named Website Design Agency of the Year at the South West England Prestige Awards 2024/25, and the 170+ Google reviews are from real clients you can look up.

  • 170+five-star Google reviews
  • 100+websites built since 2020
  • 10+years of design experience
How it works

From first call to launch in four steps.

  1. Free 15-minute call

    Tell us about the business, who you want more of and where you work. We look at your current site and say plainly what we would change.

  2. Audit and plan

    We review what ranks, what competitors do and what your customers search for, then agree the pages, the content and a fixed written quote.

  3. Design, build and test

    We design for phones first, build in WordPress, write or tidy the content and test speed, forms and the booking calendar before anything goes live.

  4. Launch and grow

    We launch with redirects in place, set up or tidy your Google Business Profile and help you build reviews and fresh content over the months that follow.

Google reviews

Real clients, real reviews.

Every review is from a client Antony has built for. Read the originals on Google.

G170+ reviewsRead them all on Google ↗
★★★★★

“Professional, dynamic and innovative web design.”

Tristan JonesGoogle review (paraphrased)
★★★★★

“Excellent communication and a result that exceeded expectations.”

Alistair Gardner · FA ConsultantGoogle review (paraphrased)
★★★★★

“An easy process for a bespoke, search-ready website.”

Nifty CurryGoogle review (paraphrased)
★★★★★

“Professional design that understood exactly what was needed.”

Julianne BarclayGoogle review (paraphrased)
★★★★★

“Careful listening and distinctive, bespoke website design.”

A&A MediaGoogle review (paraphrased)
★★★★★

“A flawless experience and a design beyond expectations.”

Gemma ChurchfieldGoogle review (paraphrased)
FAQs

Local designer vs agency vs Wix: your questions answered.

Can’t see your question? Call 07388 210030 or email info@creativelocker.co.uk.

Is Wix or Squarespace good enough?

For a simple site, yes. They are well built platforms. The difference comes from the content, structure and local set-up, which most DIY sites lack.

Is a local designer better than an agency?

Not always, but for most small businesses a local designer gives better value and more direct contact. Large projects may suit an agency.

Can a DIY site rank on Google?

Yes, if the pages are useful, fast and well structured. The platform is rarely the limit. Time and expertise usually are.

Why choose someone local?

You get someone who knows the area, can meet if needed and answers the phone. We are based in Christchurch, Dorset.

Can you move my Wix or Squarespace site?

Yes. We migrate sites to WordPress and keep what is working. See our Wix and Squarespace migration page.

What if I want to stay on my current platform?

That is fine. We will tell you honestly whether it will meet your goals or hold you back.

Which is cheapest in the long run?

Often a well-built custom site with low running costs, or a pay monthly package if you want everything bundled. Compare three-year totals.

Free 15-minute call

Talk to a web designer who builds for enquiries.

Tell us about your business and what you want the website to do. We will explain the options in plain English and give you a fixed quote. No obligation, no jargon.

Ready when you are

Not sure which route is right?

Book a free 15-minute call and we will give you an honest view.